A county code enforcement officer visited the house and asked Jones' wife about the weekly Bible studies. “She said, `Do you say `Amen?" And my wife said, "Well, yes," Jones recalled. “And she said, `Do you say `Praise The Lord?’ She said, "Well, yes.’ What would that have to do with it?"
Chandra Wallar, the general manager of the County’s Land Use and Environment Group, was asked by the news station if these were really the kind of questions that County officials would ask. She responded that what the “officer was trying to do is establish what the use is so that we know what regulations to actually utilize.”* In other words, the County’s principle concern was that the Jones’s activity was drawing enough people to their home that it became a nuisance to one of the neighbors. The person who filed the complaint is anonymous so we have no idea whether he or she was motivated by general annoyance or by a more specific antipathy toward religion. Regardless of the complainant’s motivations, the County has proceeded to handle the situation in a clumsy way that has garnered nationwide attention. Based upon the evidence so far, this does not appear to be a case of government intentionally seeking to curb religious expression. Rather, it is an unfortunate example of our country’s increasing propensity to view personal conflict through the ridiculous prism of regulations and ordinances without any consideration of common sense principles of being a good neighbor. Wouldn’t it have been better for everyone involved if the person who had filed the complaint had been encouraged to simply talk with David Jones and let him know what the concerns were? If it was simply a matter of parking space, then surely the Pastor could have come to some compromise that would have satisfied everyone.
Instead an “investigator” was dispatched to the Jones’s house to see whether the assembly at their house could be described as an “unlawful use of land”. A citation was issued because the fact that Bible study participants said “amen” and “praise the Lord” obviously meant that a major violation of land use was occurring. Pastor Jones was subsequently informed that the whole mess could be cleared up if he would only apply for a “major use permit” that apparently makes it legal for him to “annoy” his neighbors with cars on the street. This nifty little permit would only cost the Pastor a few thousand dollars. Even if Jones came up with the cash for a permit, does San Diego County really believe that the person who made the complaint would be happy with the cars being parked on the street as long as he knew that the Joneses had paid a year’s salary to make it legal? I somehow doubt it.
As the case currently stands this is not at heart a religious liberties issue. (Although, if the ineptitude of County officials continues unabated it could soon become one.) Essentially, this is about neighbors who need to sit down and have a heart to heart chat about the Tuesday night parking situation and see if come mutually satisfying agreement can be reached. I doubt seriously whether the person who filed the complaint ever spoke to the Joneses about it, and it is unlikely that he ever will. Instead we are likely to see laws and litigation used where conversation and compromise should have been. Appealing to the authorities should be a method of final resort rather than the default method used to arbitrate disputes between neighbors. Only after personal contact and dialogue has been attempted and failed would it be time to seek redress in the courts and to appeal to the government. Let us pray that sanity will ultimately prevail in this situation and someone in the San Diego County government will become acquainted with this proverb: “If you and your neighbor have a difference of opinion, settle it between yourselves and do not reveal any secrets. Otherwise … you will never live down the shame.” (Proverbs 25.9-10 [TEV])
* http://www.10news.com/news/19595677/detail.html
* You can see an interview with the Joneses at this web address. http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,522637,00.html
